|
Transportation
Studies
|
Cost
Consequences
Klingle Road remains a 90-foot right of way on the federal-aid system. The
District Division of Transportation under the District of Columbia
Department of Public Works, is responsible for the maintenance of
Klingle Road. As a federal-aid road, Klingle Road qualifies for 80
percent federal funding.
The cost to repair Klingle Road to it's original alignment is $3.8M (see
Berger figures below). This is less than originally estimated
($5.5M) back in June 2000. We will spend more than half that just to build
a gravel utility road. The $2M difference would build about 1,000 feet of
street (less than a quarter mile). Repairing Klingle Road to its
original alignment will benefit everyone.
Department of Public Works Response to the Questions Before the
Committee of Public Works and the Environment, June 7, 2000:
QUESTION:
Please describe what weight the survey results have in DPW's final
decision on Klingle Road? What weight will cost factors
carry? What other factors will carry weight in the process?
ANSWER (by Director DPW): "The Department of Publics Works is not
conducting a survey as part of the study. Cost will not be a
major consideration in the development of the final recommendation.
Traffic, public safety and environmental impacts of the alternatives
being considered will be the major elements guiding our
recommendation. However, the recommendations of the Department
will be based on the traffic issues,
environmental
impacts of the alternatives as well as the concerns
of the community."
QUESTION: Provide an
estimated timeline and cost estimate for implementing each option:
ANSWER:
Implementation Schedule
COST
|
1. No
Action
2001
None
|
2. Repair Storm Water Drainage
Only
2002
$2.5M
|
3. Remove Roadway and Return to
Natural Environment
2002
$3.0M
|
4. Bicycle/Pedestrian/Recreation
Facility
2003
$4.0M
|
5. Repair
Roadway
2003
$5.5M
|
5. Repair Roadway, add
Bicycle/Pedestrian
Path
2003
$5.5M
|
New Figures taken from the Berger Feasibility Study,
August 2001
(Rebuilding Cost Are Now Less):
|
A. No
Action
$ 272,000
|
B. No
Build
$ 858,000
|
C. Green
Space
$1,107,000
|
D. Bike, Recreation, and Management
Facility
$1,131,000
|
E. Rebuild Klingle to Original
Alignment
$3,810,000
|
F. Build Klingle Road to Accommodate
Vehicular, Pedestrian and Bike
Use
$5,170,000
|
G. Build Klingle Road as a One Lane
(1-Way) Road and a Pedestrian/Bicycle Lane $3,515,000
|
At the December 13, 2001 Mayor's Press
Conference, DDOT Director Dan Tangherlini said: "The 9
million dollars a mile it would cost to reconstruct this road is almost
exactly equivalent to what we will spend on the reconstruction of 16th
Street from Alaska Avenue to the Maryland Border, and that's six lanes
worth of road."
The closed portion of 2-lane Klingle Road is only .7 of a mile
long. Mr. Tangherlini's statement (and math) makes no
sense.
|
|